In a recent chat on Slate, a reader asked advice columnist Emily Yoffe what she should do about her friend, who had had a one-night stand that she later said was rape. The reader stated that the friend had been "beating herself up over drinking too much and going home with a guy she met at the bar" but that she later decided she had been date raped; she called a rape crisis hotline, who told her that a woman can't give consent when she's intoxicated. The friend wants to press charges against the guy, and the reader wanted to know what she should say or do to help/stop her friend. Yoffe summed up the incident as "a poor way to address one's alcohol and self-control problems. Since her first version of the story is that she was ashamed of her behavior, and since you have seen her knee-walking drunk on other occasions, it sounds as if she wants to punish the guy at the bar for her own poor choices."
"I think cases like the one you are describing here—in the absence of any evidence she was drugged—where someone voluntarily goes home with a stranger in order to have a sexual encounter, makes it that much harder for women who are assaulted to bring charges," Yoffe wrote. "Tell her that she needs to think very long and hard about filing a criminal complaint against this guy if there's any way her behavior could be construed to be consensual. Say you understand her shame, but you're concerned about her drinking, and if she addresses that, she won't find herself in such painful situations."
I think Yoffe missed the mark on this answer, and I think readers and other responders missed it as well. Many immediately began blaming the woman for her alcohol consumption, writing, for example, "I have very limited sympathy for a grown woman who goes to a bar alone, gets sloppy drunk yet again, blearily agrees to go home with someone she just met there, sleeps with him, and then days later says she was raped." The same writer said the woman should be more proactive: "She could have controlled her drinking at the bar. She could have asked a few friends to come with her, she could have asked someone to keep an eye on her. She could have slipped the bouncer a $20 and said 'if you see me drunk trying to leave with someone tonight, please stop me,' she could have pulled enough sense out of her drunken brain to say 'no' herself when this guy asked if she 'WANTED to go back to his place.'"
There are a lot of problems with this discussion about one night stands, date rape, drunken behaviors and consent. The first, though, is that the original poster never asked her friend whether she said "no" during the encounter. I think the assumption was that the friend didn't say "no," but I'm not sure it's a fair assumption. I see two red flags from her friend's behavior: (1) she was beating herself up over her decision-making; and (2) she called a rape crisis hotline. A lot of women who have been date raped feel shame and ashamed after being raped. Victim-blaming is part of our culture, and many victims initially blame themselves for what happened to them. Few women want to have been raped, and so many may try to rationalize it away in some way or another just to cope. And the letter-writing "friend" said she believes her friend has a drinking problem and has had one-night stands before; but it doesn't seem that she normally calls rape crisis hotlines after such adventures, just this particular incident. So it seems her friend understands that her other one-night stands were just drunken attempts at sexual gratification. Maybe this one was different, and it took her a while to wrap her mind around how: he was more forceful, he scared her, he bullied her, he wouldn't take no for an answer.
Or, maybe not. Maybe the letter-writer is right and this is a girl who just got drunk and regretted it the next morning, regretted it more than usual for one reason or another that had nothing to do with the guy's behavior. Either way, it's an important lead-in to a big discussion/challenge in the rape victim advocacy arena: the issue of drunken consent. This is an issue that polarizes women from each other, women from men, and men from having a thoughtful understanding of what rape is.
First, let's state the obvious: a drunk woman can consent to sex. I've done it many times myself. I think most women have, and we look back on those times, you know, rather fondly. I could talk about just last night, but I won't. So for rape crisis centers or advocates to say that a drunk woman cannot give consent to sex, as the letter-writer described, is ... I don't want to say it's ridiculous, but then, I do. I understand why they say this: there's so much woman-blaming and woman-hating out there and its necessary for prosecution. But it's polarizing because it's just not true.
Second (and this is something some people miss): A person can drink to a point in which they are no longer able to care for themselves; if someone is passed-out intoxicated, they cannot consent to sex. For a person to consent to sex, they have to be able to say and decide "yes" or "no."
Third: A person can change their mind at any time as to whether or not they want to have sex. So, consent to go to a person's home is not consent to have sex. It's also not consent to steal from them, murder them, kidnap them, take home videos of them, etc.
So let's say you're Guy and you're at the bar with Girl, who is five glasses in and suggests going back to your place. "We'll have a good time together," she teases, and it seems pretty promising. "You'll just have to give me a ride to my car in the morning." Now it seems super promising. "Okay," Guy says. "But it's a little messy." So you go and you drive down the road, and the girl starts to sober up and realize that maybe she needs to slow down a bit, here. What was your last name again? Maybe she's seen a lot of police dramas. Is this guy going to murder me in my sleep? So now she's in Guy's car, she's torn, she's finding herself in a bad spot and is hoping that she didn't royally mess up. "So describe your place," she says, trying to make small talk and get some information she probably should've gotten earlier. "Where do you live, exactly?" Guy says he lives on the East Side. Girl opens her phone and starts texting a friend. Dude! Had a few drinks tonight. Met a guy named Charlie. Lives on the East Side. If I die tonight, tell the police so they can find my body. You know, something to play it safe. She's doing what she thinks she should be doing: taking chances, living it up, telling a trusted friend where she'll be. Guy and Girl get back to Guy's place and Guy offers Girl something more to drink. Well, Girl thinks, it's gone okay so far.
Everything up to this point is fine, but this is where things might get dicey. Coming home with Guy does not mean Guy can have sex with Girl. Coming home just means his chances of that happening are better. If Girl passes out, changes her mind (she sees his naked women posters everywhere, or a cockroach, or he's just not doing it for her or whatever) says she wants to slow it down, etc, then one of two things will happen: Guy will be Good, or Guy will be Total Asshole. Good Guy will say, "okay, I totally understand, it's late anyway. You can sleep on the couch and I'll drive you to your car in the morning." Total Asshole would say "Oh, come on, you came over here drunk, you said you wanted to have sex, I still want to have sex," thus escalating the situation into what could become a date-rape scenario in which a girl calls her best friend the next day, ashamed about what happened, says it was just a one-night stand, and then later calls a rape crisis hotline and decides it was rape.
Still, a lot of people would still be quick to blame Girl in this scenario (the same people would most likely blame Guy if Guy and Girl had consensual sex and Girl stole his wallet, etc, even though, in that situation, Guy would be the victim). That's what many readers and commentators of Yoffe's column did. Why? There seems to be this sense of "but what's a guy to do?" in these scenarios, or of "an accusation of this one night could destroy this guy's life." Few people get upset at the guy's judgment here, at his inability to control himself when he's drinking, his inability to adapt to the situation or his inability to understand consent. Many people seem to think Guy is the victim. Guy is not the victim. Guy is generally stronger, has a higher tolerance for alcohol, and has the ability to do right or wrong.
Now, a generally Good Guy might find out that he can turn into Total Asshole one night of his life. He's angry about something, just broke up with his ex, he finds a drunk girl who seems gung-ho, she backs off, he gets aggressive, one thing leads to another, they have "bad sex," girl decides to just call a cab, he thinks it was just a regretful one night stand, but she starts to see it as something much worse, and soon she's calling him a rapist. Guy no longer cares what Girl feels. Guy's whole life could be ruined if Girl decides to press charges. Guy doesn't understand that rape, even date-rape, is a traumatic experience for a woman. Guy holds on to his Rationalization Thoughts that allowed the sex to occur in the first place. In his mind, it wasn't rape, anyway. He now has his own trauma to deal with, and that trauma is called Girl. But Guy is not a Monster. Guy is just Guy who, like girl, got drunk one night and now is worse off for it.
I think that for men and women to all come to an understanding of what date rape is, we need to have an open conversation about it that doesn't involve victim-blaming and doesn't necessarily make every man accused of date rape into a monster (there are definitely predatory monsters out there, and if women don't come forward about date rape, it makes it impossible to stop predators.) It should be a conversation based on respect, on treating others morally, on actually explaining to men what the emotional and long-term effects of nonconsensual sex are. Nonconsensual sex is a big deal. It brings shame (why wasn't I smarter than that?), it brings worry (what if I'm pregnant/got an STD?), it brings a realization that you cannot always help yourself (anybody could out power me, I can't trust anybody). The fear and the loss of control one might feel after being date-raped can change a person, and a person's health, fundamentally. Date-rape is not "a bad situation," to make the most of, as Rick Santorum has said. It is a violation into a person's physical body and emotional health. It is a lack of empathy and morals. It is forcefully taking control of another person's body and sexuality. It is the loss of control over one's own sexuality.
Date rape is a big deal. It's not something that any woman should be blamed for. It's something that needs to be discussed. But it's also something that needs to be more nuanced than it is. Men accused of date-rape aren't necessarily monsters, but they need to be told that what happened last night wasn't sex. They need to be aware that they need to do some soul searching. They need to be aware that there are consequences for their actions, that they've traumatized another human being. They need to make amends. And if someone actively preys on vulnerable women, drunk women or poor women, they need to be held accountable. This is not a survival of the fittest world. It's a civil society where the strong look out for the weak, and where laws protect those who need protecting.
I can't believe I even had to write all that.
No comments:
Post a Comment