I've considered myself a Strong Woman for a while now. I worked hard all through high school, getting (nearly) straight A's while holding down full-time jobs to support any extras I needed. I applied to one college, the University of Michigan, without a fallback plan, knowing beyond a shadow of a doubt that the hard work would pay off, that I'd be accepted, that it was where I was meant to be. I took 18 credits of classes a semester, worked full-time at the student newspaper and 30 hours a week at a one-hour photo lab to gain the experience I'd need to pursue a career I was passionate about while still paying for my rent, my food, my books. I did it, and I'm proud of it.
But too much pride is a sin, and it's often come back to hurt me in my relationships, where I have often assumed the role as the breadwinner. The college education I worked so hard for, busted my ass for, has left me in a bit of a pickle: do I take ownership over my accomplishments, do I take credit for my intelligence, do I present myself as an Independent Woman, or do I acquiesce to traditional feminine-masculine roles and stereotypes despite the reality of the situation in which I am in? I am proud to be a breadwinner, but does my pride emasculate the men I am with?
A lot of people, some of my closest friends and certainly the men I've been with, believe it does. Men believe they can take pride in paying for things, in being independent, in making money, in having successful careers, but when a woman they are with takes pride in those things, it's hurtful, shameful and emasculating toward them; it defies their idea of what a man is, what a man does, who a man should be.
I don't want to emasculate a man by taking credit for my accomplishments and for wanting recognition for being the breadwinner, for expecting a certain gratitude and appreciation for when I pay for things that breadwinners pay for; as a woman, the importance of gratitude and appreciation for those things have been drilled into me since I was a child, a teenager, a young adult. But I'm a woman; I was expected to be treated, not to treat. Boys weren't taught gratitude and appreciation like girls were. They were taught that hard work pays off, that if they wanted something they must work for it, that favors are returned and success is rewarded.
Times have changed, but our idea of what it means to be a man and what it means to be a woman have largely not, or are changing more slowly. Masculinity and femininity and the value of a man or a woman shouldn't be defined by who pays the bills or who wears the pants and makes decisions or who cooks dinner the best; in a feminist society in which men and women are equals, those things are interchangeable and dependent on each person's skills, passions, interests, values, backgrounds and a myriad of other non-gendered factors. That isn't to say I don't have an idea of the characteristics I am looking for in a man, or a general idea of what makes a Man. But I would say my ideas are flexible, more liquid than solid.
A man, to me, is someone who protects those who can't protect themselves. A real man will protect someone else before he protects himself; not physically, necessarily, but in any way in which he can protect. A real man will defend the rights of other men, even if he doesn't entirely agree with those men; a real man will intervene when the wellbeing of another is in jeopardy. A desire to protect is an inherent trait of masculinity.
A man will provide what he can to others and realize that being a provider is more difficult and complex than making money. Being a provider means offering emotional and mental support when times get challenging or draining; it means stepping outside of your own mind and your own problems to aid others with theirs. A man knows the most valuable things he can give to someone or something else is his energy, his commitment to a cause, his time, his intelligence, his dedication. A desire to provide is an inherent trait of masculinity.
A man will lead, or respect those who are leaders — not because they are the leader but because they should be the leader. A man will see the value in others according to their character and will pick them up or bring them down based on that character. A man will follow those who deserve followers and will lead those who need a leader. A man will do what is necessary for the common good and will accept his place within that cause, within that battle. He won't be driven by ego or by self-interest.
A man will recognize his faults and work always to improve himself. He will love himself, but not to a fault; he will see his weaknesses and work to turn them into strengths. He will find the power within himself to be better but not hate himself for his imperfections. A man will approach his journey with vigor and determination, knowing it will never end; he will never see the summit. He will always, every day, be learning.
A man will define himself. He will create his own dreams, his own path, his own value; he will not let society determine who he is, what he should want, how he should success or what he should accomplish. He will decide his own life for himself and rest peacefully with those decisions, knowing why he made them and knowing that they were right for him and knowing that nothing is undoable.
And what about a woman? What is a woman, when traditional gender roles aren't defining who we are and what we should be?
A woman, to me, is someone who is open. She doesn't hide behind anything — not a man, not her family, not her upbringing. A woman is willing to share her thoughts, her feelings, her emotions, her accomplishments to build a better world, however small that world may be — to strengthen the bonds of her family, of her workplace, of her friends. A woman is transparent.
A woman is tender. A woman wants to fix the bruises left from the hardships of the world — bruises on the skin, on the heart, on the mind. A woman fights hate with love, aggressiveness with compassion, murder with birth, jealousy with giving. A woman practices empathy, always.
A woman is resilient. She doesn't harden, no matter how hard life is. She doesn't give up, no matter how far behind she is. She doesn't shatter, no matter how small she is. When things get scary, she will be brave. When things get dark, she will see light. When the world weighs on her shoulders, she will stand up and with back straight and her head high.
A woman knows her strengths. A woman won't value herself based on her flaws, but on her strengths; she will see the value of her intelligence or her grace or her humor and will love herself for it. She will not let others determine her value or her worth, will not let the world undervalue her because she is not the most beautiful, the most intelligent, the most driven or the most motherly. She doesn't have to be the most anything, other than the most herself.
But the more I write, the more I want to say: This is all bullshit. Masculinity and femininity are bullshit, ideas created because our society simplifies humans to the point where we all become Tetris pieces, wondering where we fit and what our role is and wanting others to tell us because it's easier that way, even when what others say doesn't ring true because we can always lie. We can lie about how open we are, how tender we are, how driven we are, how much pride we have, whether we value ourselves and what we value about ourselves. What we need to realize is that humans are not Tetris pieces. We were not shaped to fit into predetermined roles with predetermined characteristics. We are like grains of sand; each of us unique, each of us valuable, each of us contributing to the beach, all of us fitting somewhere. A woman who protects those she loves, who provides for her family, who accepts her roles as a leader and a follower, who recognizes her faults is every bit as much a woman as one who is open, tender, resilient and who values her strengths. A man who is open, tender, resilient and who knows his strengths is every bit as much of a man as a man who protects, provides, leads, follows, improves son his faults and determines his own path.
It's time to stop thinking about masculinity and femininity altogether and focus on individuality, on personhood. It's time to value the characteristics once associated as masculine or feminine equally, without assignment, without bias, without stereotype, without degrading those traits based on gender. A man who is tender is just as valuable as a woman who is tender. A woman who is intelligent is just as valuable as a man who is intelligent. Tenderness and intelligence should not compete with each other, but compliment each other; there is not one that is better than the other because both are necessary in the world, wherever they are found.